Emily Weiner and Avi Bernstein-Nahar respond to Adam Bellow on teaching American history
To the Editor:
I embrace Adam Bellow’s call, in his article “A New Battle of the Books,” for “a revised and updated account of Western and American civilization—warts and all, incorporating what is legitimate in the anti-Western critique—that shows the positive arc of this tradition and its unique contribution to human freedom and prosperity.”
However, by joining other Jewish intellectuals in the current clamor of broad-brush rejection of “critical race theory, DEI, intersectionality, anticolonialism, cultural Marxism, and related disciplines,” he is limiting his ability to contribute to a new “shared identity we once took for granted.” His use of the word “we” points to whose histories are essential to create a new shared identity.
It has been a monumental task (which Howard Zinn greatly contributed to) over many decades to add to the American story facts about women, Native Americans, black people, people with disabilities, queer people, workers whose labor has been harshly exploited, and many immigrants, including Jewish immigrants. Of course, it is a harmful distortion to reduce these facts to a “simplistic morality tale in which everything Western is bad and everything non-Western is good.” (And the influence of the Soviets and their adherents, Iran, Qatar, and other Islamists in fostering this simplistic morality tale and promoting antisemitism must be publicized.) But we who oppose what Left academics have been teaching—including but not limited to the lies that Israel is a settler-colonialist state and that antisemitic actions are righteous—will not be able to offer an American story that is compelling to young people who now believe the ideologies of either the anti-Zionist Left or the white-nationalist Right unless we thoroughly synthesize both pride in the liberal tradition and analysis of how slavery, racism, conquests of Indigenous peoples, and hypocrisy have been essential components in the development of capitalism and the texts of the liberal canon.
I am seeing a trend of Jewish intellectuals aligning with the anti-liberal Right’s broad-brush rejection of these critiques of Western society. This trend is undermining efforts to tell an inclusive and compelling American story that can compete for the hearts and minds of young people around the world, including our Jewish youth who have joined the ranks of their anti-Zionist peers.
Emily Weiner
Bellingham, Washington
To the Editor:
I read Adam Bellow’s essay “A New Battle of the Books” with interest. It’s refreshing to encounter an unapologetic assertion of the power of books to influence the outcome of this fraught cultural moment. Bellow is correct to draw attention to the role that book-length argument has played in sapping our “civilizational confidence” and undermining a shared American identity, and he’s right to call on Jews to push back.
I was happy to learn that Jewish publishers in particular once took the lead in disseminating the virtues of Western liberalism, the very liberalism now under attack. But Bellow’s essay contains some ironies that should be uncovered and confronted.
It may or may not be that Mortimer Adler and Will and Ariel Durant, who were engaged in popularization of the classics, are role models for this moment. That’s worth debating. But even the mere mention of Adler in the course of an accounting for America’s 20th-century cultural-political evolution should strike Jewish readers as menacing. What SAPIR readers may not know is that Adler, a champion of the Catholic canon, was a self-declared Thomist and a booster for the power of discursive argument, but he nevertheless had the gall to promote “conversation” without any reference to the rabbinic tradition. While as a matter of principle I resist reductive explanation, given the assimilatory pressures and internalized antisemitism commonplace in this historical period, it’s hard to avoid the impression that Adler, who converted to Catholicism at the end of his life, was a self-hating Jew and ignorant of the very civilization that should have concerned him as a scholar of the Western tradition. He certainly is not one to whom Jewish publishers and would-be Jewish authors should look for inspiration.
One might be able to tell a similar story about Ariel Durant, born Chaya Kaufman.
The larger context for my perspective is this: Let us as Jews not merely operate as publishers and writers addressing the Enlightenment foundations of liberalism, a worthy enterprise to be sure. Let us lead and in doing so address ourselves to the Jewish foundations of liberalism in particular, and to the fruitful dialogue that once took place between the Protestant Enlightenment and European Jewish intellectuals. In other words, as Jewish publishers and writers, let us consider how Judaism is bound up with our highest hopes and aspirations for the future of the West, and for the State of Israel, which may or may not remain an outpost of it.
For this project, we will need to go not to the likes of Adler, Durant, and David Brooks, Jews in full retreat, but to proud self-affirming and inquiring Jews such as Hermann Cohen, Ahad Ha’am, Louis Brandeis, Rabbi Mordecai Kaplan, Rabbi Milton Steinberg, Louis Finkelstein, Dennis Prager, Abraham Joshua Heschel, and Rabbi Sharon Brous.
And this, I assure you: Every one of these writers, despite their considerable differences, would encourage their readers to, among other things, return to the Torah, the source of Jewish values, to the skillful conversational mode of the Talmudic sages, and to the searching, grappling Jewish texts of European modernity.
None of these proud and knowledgeable Jews would concede that liberalism is an exclusive product of the Christian West or of the “Judeo-Christian” tradition—that vague entity of recent vintage. On the contrary, each in his or her own way would take up the thesis that Jewish civilization, its values, and the people who carry it on their shoulders are called to be “a light unto the nations” (Isaiah 42:6) and shall remain, now and in the future, here in America and elsewhere, champions of the stranger, outsiders looking in, and insiders looking out, and, above all, the “People of Book.”
Avi Bernstein-Nahar
Newton Highlands, Massachusetts
Adam Bellow responds:
I thank Avi Bernstein-Nahar and Emily Weiner for their engagement with my essay, but I fear that they are projecting their own preoccupations onto what I have written.
At the core of Bernstein-Nahar’s lengthy critique of my article appears to be a misunderstanding about what it is that secular Jewish publishers do. To be clear, it is not specifically our role to promote those whom a scholar might consider the most authoritative Jewish thinkers. Still less is it our task to call Jewish readers to the Torah. Our mission is to tell the Jewish story. If that story includes Jewish educators like Mortimer Adler, or the Jewish businessmen who published Will and Ariel Durant, who in their different ways promoted the Western liberal tradition on which the safety and security of American Jews continues to depend, we make no bones about their personal beliefs or whether they were good or bad as people, or as Jews. That said, we do consider it our role to affirm the Jewish roots of that tradition and have consistently done so. Examples from my own imprint include The Builder’s Stone: How Jews and Christians Built the West—And Why Only They Can Save It, by Melanie Phillips, and the forthcoming The Hebraic Thread: Reclaiming the Political Theology That Sustains the Liberal West, by Alan Bekhor.
Emily Weiner seems genuinely torn between her admirably clear understanding of the ideological threat to Jewish safety from the Left and her (equally ideological) fear and dislike of the Right. I’m afraid I can’t help her with that. Not if she wishes me to see the good and positive intentions behind DEI and similarly divisive educational and publishing initiatives, or to deepen my critique of the “lies” that were previously told about American history. I am happy to acknowledge the deficiencies of the previous American story. But I have given enough ground to Howard Zinn and do not agree that we as Jewish publishers must focus more on America’s sins than on those of other nations and empires going back to Babylonia. Down that path lies cultural despair and civilizational suicide in the name of a moral standard that no society ever has or can achieve. If one’s conception of Jewish identity requires endorsement of that kind of project, the best I can muster is to encourage that person to start her own publishing business, and we’ll duke it out in the marketplace.